Beyond the Percentages: Why I Ditched the Budgeting Rulebook and What I Learned from My Garden Instead

For the first decade of my career as a financial coach, my world was built on a foundation of rules.

My spreadsheets were masterpieces of color-coded precision, my advice was crisp and absolute, and my office shelves were lined with the gospel of personal finance gurus.

I believed, with every fiber of my being, in the power of a perfect plan.

I preached the doctrine of percentages and the discipline of a zero-based budget.

And for some people, it worked.

But for too many, it didn’t.

I saw the same story play out over and over.

Intelligent, motivated people would walk into my office, desperate for control over their money.

They were drowning in the common struggles of modern financial life: the relentless pressure of credit card debt that grows through compounding interest, the anxiety of not having an emergency fund for unexpected car repairs or medical bills, and the feeling of spending more than they earned without knowing where the money went.¹

We would sit down, build what I considered a “perfect” budget, and they would leave full of hope.

A few months later, they’d be back, shoulders slumped, defeated.

They weren’t just broke; they were ashamed.

They felt they had failed the system.

It took me far too long to realize the truth: the system was failing them.

The moment of reckoning, the event that shattered my rigid worldview, came in the form of a client I’ll call Anna.

Anna was a brilliant freelance graphic designer, the kind of creative talent you knew was destined for great things.

She was also the poster child for the modern economy: her income was a rollercoaster of feast and famine, tied to client projects and payment schedules.²

She came to me feeling overwhelmed, a classic case of a high earner with nothing to show for it.⁴

Following the standard playbook, we implemented a strict, Ramsey-style, zero-based budget.

We listed her expenses and dutifully followed the advice for irregular income: anchor your budget to your lowest-earning month.⁵

On paper, it was flawless.

In reality, it was a psychological torture device.

In her “lean” months, the budget was so tight it squeaked, generating constant stress.

In her “feast” months, she had a huge surplus with no systemic plan to allocate it, leading to impulsive spending.

The budget, which was supposed to be a tool of empowerment, became a monthly report card on which she was constantly getting a failing grade.

It didn’t account for the ebb and flow of her life.

It was a rigid blueprint for a world that no longer existed for many people, a world of predictable, bi-weekly paychecks.

The stress led her to avoid looking at her finances, and she fell back on using credit cards to smooth out the cash-flow gaps her “perfect” budget couldn’t handle.

She ended up deeper in debt and felt worse than when she started.

Anna’s failure was my failure.

It forced me to confront the uncomfortable truth that the blueprints I was selling were fundamentally flawed.

I had been trying to fit the beautiful, messy, organic chaos of a human life into a spreadsheet.

And it was breaking people.

The Problem with a One-Size-Fits-All Financial World

Anna’s story sent me down a rabbit hole, forcing me to critically re-examine the very foundations of my profession.

The dominant budgeting philosophies, while well-intentioned, are built on a similar premise: that there is a “correct” way to allocate your money, and that this can be expressed as a set of universal percentages.

The two most prevalent models are the detailed percentage-based system, most famously championed by Dave Ramsey, and the simpler 50/30/20 rule.

• The Ramsey Model: This approach is built on the concept of a zero-based budget, where every dollar of your take-home pay is assigned a job before the month begins. The simple formula is your total monthly income minus your total monthly expenses equals zero.⁶ To guide this process, Ramsey Solutions provides recommended percentage ranges for various spending categories. These guidelines suggest allocating specific portions of your income to everything from housing and food to giving and insurance.⁸
• The 50/30/20 Rule: Popularized by Senator Elizabeth Warren in her book, All Your Worth: The Ultimate Lifetime Money Plan, this rule offers a simpler, broader framework. It suggests dividing your after-tax income into three buckets: 50% for “Needs” (essentials like housing, food, and transportation), 30% for “Wants” (discretionary spending like hobbies and dining out), and 20% for “Savings” (including debt repayment beyond minimums).¹⁰

The core issue with both models is not their logic, but their collision with reality.

They present a prescriptive ideal of how a household should spend its money, but for a vast number of people, this ideal is simply unattainable.

The gap between the guidelines and the actual cost of living in the 21st century is no longer a crack; it’s a chasm.

Ramsey Solutions’ own analysis of the 50/30/20 rule highlights this disconnect.

They point out that for the median US household, essential expenses like housing, food, transportation, and healthcare consume, on average, over 80% of their take-home pay.¹⁰

This makes capping “Needs” at 50% a mathematical impossibility for the average family.

Similarly, Ramsey’s housing guideline of 25-35% of take-home pay, while a noble goal, is profoundly unrealistic for anyone with a median income living in or near a major US city.⁷

When one category, like housing, is forced to consume 40%, 50%, or even more of a person’s income, the entire percentage-based pie chart crumbles.⁷

This isn’t a failure of willpower on the part of the individual; it’s a failure of the model to reflect the economic environment.

The following table illustrates this conflict by placing the popular guidelines alongside the real-world spending data from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS).

Budget Category	Ramsey Guideline (%)	50/30/20 Rule (Implied %)	BLS Average Household Expenditure (2023, %)
Housing	25–35%		32.9%
Transportation	10–15%	Needs (Total 50%)	17.0%
Food	5–15%		12.9%
Healthcare	5–10%		8.0%
Total “Needs”	(Implied 45-75%+)	50%	(Implied 70.8%+)
Personal Insurance & Pensions (Savings)	10–15%	20%	12.4%
Entertainment / Recreation (Wants)	5–10%	30%	4.7%
Cash Contributions (Giving)	10–15%	(Part of Wants)	3.1%

Sources: ⁹

As the table clearly shows, the average American household’s spending on just four essential categories—housing, transportation, food, and healthcare—already exceeds 70% of their total expenditures.

This leaves precious little room for the other categories to fit within their prescribed boxes.

The most damaging consequence of this disconnect is psychological.

The world of personal finance is often framed as a moral battleground.

“Budget culture,” as some critics call it, can weaponize discipline and shame, implying that financial struggles are a personal failing rather than a symptom of a flawed system.¹⁴

When people like Anna try to follow these “foolproof” plans and fail, they don’t question the blueprint; they question themselves.

This creates a vicious cycle of guilt, anxiety, and avoidance—the very emotions that prevent clear-headed financial progress.

The Gardener’s Epiphany

My disillusionment with the old models sent me into a period of reflection.

I temporarily stopped taking on new clients and dedicated my time to understanding the fundamental disconnect.

The problem, I realized, wasn’t just in the numbers, but in the guiding metaphor.

We treat our finances like a machine to be engineered or a building to be constructed.

We talk about “financial architecture,” “building wealth,” and “blueprints for success.” These metaphors imply a static, predictable, controllable process.

But life is not a machine.

It’s an ecosystem.

It is organic, dynamic, and stubbornly unique to each individual.

The real breakthrough, the epiphany that would reshape my entire approach, came from the most unexpected of places: my own backyard.

I had been trying, with mounting frustration, to force a vegetable garden into a series of perfectly straight, tidy rows.

I was imposing my will on the land, and the land was resisting.

The plants in the shady corner struggled; the ones on the slope were constantly dry.

It was a high-effort, low-yield disaster.

Fed up, I picked up a book on a design philosophy I’d heard about but never explored: permaculture.

The core idea of permaculture was a revelation.

Instead of imposing a rigid, artificial grid onto a piece of land, a permaculturist begins with a period of quiet observation.

They study the unique contours of the landscape: the path of the sun, the flow of water, the quality of the soil, the existing microclimates.

Only after understanding the natural patterns do they begin to design.

The goal is to create a self-regulating, resilient, and productive ecosystem that works with the land, not against it.

A permaculture garden isn’t built; it’s cultivated.

It embraces diversity, captures energy, and adapts to change.

It is designed to be resilient to shocks like drought, pests, or unexpected weather.

Reading this, it felt like a lightning bolt had struck my office.

This was it.

This was the metaphor I had been searching for.

A budget shouldn’t be a rigid cage we try to force our lives into.

A financial plan should be a living system we cultivate, one that is uniquely designed for the contours of our own personal landscape. This was the birth of a new framework, one that moved beyond prescriptive rules and into holistic design: Financial Permaculture.

Introducing Financial Permaculture: A Framework for Budgets That Bend, Not Break

Financial Permaculture is not another set of rigid percentages or a one-size-fits-all plan.

It is a design philosophy for managing your money that is built on four key principles, drawn directly from the wisdom of the garden.

It’s a way to create a financial life that is not only organized but also resilient, adaptive, and, most importantly, aligned with who you are and the life you actually live.

It’s about shifting your mindset from that of a frustrated architect trying to force a flawed blueprint onto an unwilling site, to that of a patient, observant gardener, cultivating a system that will thrive.

The Principles of Financial Permaculture

This framework is built upon four pillars that work together to create a resilient and productive financial ecosystem.

Each pillar represents a shift in mindset and a set of practical actions that move you from a place of rigid rule-following to empowered, conscious design.

Pillar 1: Observe & Interact – The No-Judgment Financial Audit

In permaculture, the first and most critical principle is to observe.

Before you plant a single seed or dig a single hole, you spend time simply watching the land.

You learn its patterns, its strengths, and its weaknesses.

You see where the sun lingers, where the water pools, and where the wind blows strongest.

This observation is done without judgment; it is a pure act of information gathering.

In personal finance, this translates to the No-Judgment Financial Audit.

Before you try to change a single spending habit, you must first understand your unique financial ecosystem.

This means tracking your money not with the immediate goal of finding what to cut, but with the simple, curious goal of seeing where it currently goes.¹⁵

This is not a moral inventory; it is a mapping expedition.

For many, this is the hardest step because we are so conditioned to associate spending with guilt.

The goal here is to temporarily suspend that guilt and become a neutral scientist of your own life.

Actionable Steps for Observation:

1. Track Everything: For at least one full month (two is even better), track every single dollar that comes in and goes out. Use a dedicated app, a spreadsheet, or a simple notebook. The tool doesn’t matter as much as the consistency. The goal is to create a complete and honest record.¹⁶
2. Categorize Honestly: As you track, categorize your spending. But go beyond simple labels like “Groceries” or “Utilities.” Be honest about your personality and lifestyle. Do you have a “Stress-Shopping” category? A “Convenience Food” category because you work late? Acknowledging your real-life patterns is crucial. You can’t design a system for a life you’re pretending to live.¹⁵
3. Map Your Financial Contours: At the end of the observation period, map out your financial landscape. Clearly identify three types of expenses:

• Fixed Expenses: These are the predictable, consistent costs each month, like rent/mortgage, car payments, and insurance premiums.¹⁷
• Variable Expenses: These are the fluctuating but regular costs, like groceries, gasoline, and utilities.
• Irregular Expenses: This is the category most budgets ignore, and it’s often what sinks them. These are the expenses that don’t happen every month but are largely predictable over the course of a year: annual subscriptions, holiday gifts, car registration, quarterly tax payments, vet visits, etc..¹⁸

By the end of this process, you will have a detailed, honest map of your personal financial ecosystem.

You haven’t changed anything yet, but for the first time, you can truly see the terrain you’re working with.

Pillar 2: Catch & Store Energy – Mastering Volatility with Financial Reservoirs

A core tenet of permaculture design is to capture resources when they are abundant and store them for use when they are scarce.

A gardener installs rain barrels to catch water during a storm to use during a drought.

They orient solar panels to catch the sun’s energy to power the home at night.

This principle of building reservoirs creates resilience and buffers the system from external shocks.

This is the most powerful solution to the problem of financial volatility, especially for those with irregular incomes like Anna, but also for anyone navigating the unpredictable expenses of life.

The traditional monthly budget is atemporal; it assumes every month is the same.

Financial Permaculture recognizes that life is seasonal.

We must design systems to catch and store our financial energy (money) during our “feast” times to sustain us through our “famine” times.

Actionable Systems for Storing Energy:

1. The One-Month Buffer (The Primary Rain Barrel): This is the single most transformative system you can build, especially if you have a variable income. The goal is to get one month ahead and live on last month’s income.²⁰ Here’s how it works: You create a separate savings or checking account that acts as a holding tank. All income you earn in the current month (say, August) gets deposited directly into this holding account and you don’t touch it. On the first day of the next month (September 1st), you transfer your entire planned budget amount from the holding tank into your primary checking account. You then live off that fixed, predictable amount for all of September. This single practice transforms a volatile, unpredictable income into a stable, predictable monthly “salary” that you pay yourself. It severs the direct link between earning and spending, eliminating the anxiety of lean weeks and the impulsive spending of rich weeks. Building this buffer may take intense focus for a few months, but the peace of mind it creates is immeasurable.
2. Sinking Funds (The Specialized Cisterns): This is the solution for the irregular expenses you identified in your audit. For every known, non-monthly expense, you create a dedicated “sinking fund,” which is simply a targeted savings account.¹⁰ For example:

• Your car insurance is $1,200 per year, due in two $600 payments. You create a sinking fund and automatically save $100 every month ($1,200 / 12). When the bill comes, the money is sitting there waiting.
• You plan to spend $600 on holiday gifts. You save $50 per month into a “Holidays” sinking fund.
• Your car registration is $240 per year. You save $20 per month.
  Sinking funds turn “surprise” budget-busting expenses into predictable, manageable monthly non-events.

3. The Emergency Fund (The Deep Well): This is your ultimate reservoir, reserved for true, unforeseen emergencies—a job loss, a major medical event, a sudden need to move.¹ It is distinct from sinking funds, which are for predictable expenses. Dave Ramsey’s Baby Steps provide an excellent model for building this deep well:

• Baby Step 1: Save a starter emergency fund of $1,000 as quickly as possible. This creates an immediate, small buffer between you and life’s minor mishaps, preventing you from reaching for a credit card.²³
• Baby Step 3: After paying off non-mortgage debt (Baby Step 2), you expand that fund to cover 3-6 months of essential living expenses. This larger fund provides true security against major life disruptions.²⁵

Together, these three reservoirs—the buffer, the sinking funds, and the emergency fund—create a system that can absorb the shocks and volatility of real life, allowing your financial plan to bend instead of break.

Pillar 3: Apply Self-Regulation & Accept Feedback – The Living Zero-Based Budget

A permaculture garden is not a static installation.

It’s a living system that requires ongoing interaction.

The gardener must constantly observe which plants are thriving and which are struggling, and make small, iterative adjustments.

This is the principle of applying self-regulation and accepting feedback.

This is where we reclaim the zero-based budget, not as a rigid set of rules, but as a dynamic, monthly feedback loop.⁶

The goal of the formula

income – expenses = 0 is not to spend everything you have or to restrict yourself needlessly.

The true power of the zero-based budget is that it forces conscious, intentional decision-making every single month.⁷

The Mindset Shift in Action:

• Start with a Blank Slate: Each month, you begin anew. You are not bound by last month’s failures or successes. You look at the predictable income you’ve paid yourself from your buffer and you create a plan for that money for this month.¹⁷
• Fund Based on Reality: You allocate funds to your categories based on the actual needs of the upcoming month, not an idealized percentage from a book. Is it a month with a birthday? Fund the “Gifts” sinking fund. Is a big utility bill expected? Plan for it.
• Embrace Feedback, Not Failure: This is the most critical shift. When you overspend in a category—and you will—the zero-sum nature of the budget provides immediate feedback. To cover the overage, you must consciously decide to move money from another category. This isn’t a sign of failure; it’s a learning opportunity. It reveals your true, in-the-moment priorities. If you consistently pull from your “New Clothes” category to fund your “Dining Out” category, your budget is teaching you what you value more. You can then adjust next month’s plan to reflect that reality, guilt-free. The budget becomes a tool for self-discovery, not self-flagellation.
• The Role of Giving as a Buffer: Within this framework, we can see Dave Ramsey’s controversial 10-15% giving guideline in a new light.⁹ While his primary justification is rooted in his Christian faith and the spiritual benefits of generosity ²⁸, from a pure systems design perspective, it serves another powerful function. A large, non-essential, discretionary category like “Giving” acts as a significant financial and psychological buffer. In a month where a true unexpected expense arises and your other funds are depleted, this is a category that can be temporarily reduced or paused without impacting your family’s survival.³⁰ It provides crucial flexibility. Furthermore, the act of intentionally setting aside money for others fosters a mindset of abundance and control, which is psychologically more powerful than a mindset of pure scarcity and restriction.

Pillar 4: Use & Value Diversity – Your Brain on Money

A central tenet of permaculture is that diversity creates resilience.

A field planted with a single crop (a monoculture) is highly efficient in a stable environment but extremely vulnerable to a single pest or disease.

A diverse garden with many different types of plants (a polyculture) is more robust, as different elements support each other and create a more stable, resilient whole.

There is no single “best” plant; there is only the right plant for the right place.

The same is true in finance.

There is no single “best” strategy for everyone.

The most effective plan is one that acknowledges and works with your unique psychological makeup, your personality, and your behavioral tendencies.³¹

Instead of fighting against your nature, you design a system that harnesses it.

The classic debate between the Debt Snowball and Debt Avalanche methods is the perfect case study for this principle.

• The Debt Avalanche (The Mathematical Optimum): This method instructs you to list your debts from the highest interest rate to the lowest. You make minimum payments on all debts and throw every extra dollar at the one with the highest interest rate. Once that’s paid off, you roll its payment into the next-highest-interest debt. Mathematically, this approach will always save you the most money in interest and get you out of debt the fastest.³²
• The Debt Snowball (The Behavioral Optimum): This method, famously advocated by Dave Ramsey, instructs you to list your debts from the smallest balance to the largest, regardless of the interest rate. You make minimum payments on all and attack the smallest balance with intensity. Once it’s gone, you roll that payment into the next-smallest debt, creating a “snowball” of momentum.²⁷

For years, financial purists mocked the Debt Snowball as mathematically foolish.

But they were missing the point.

They were ignoring the human element.

Behavioral economics and psychological studies have shown that for many people, the Debt Snowball is far more effective in practice.³⁴

The reason is motivation.

Paying off that first small debt, regardless of the interest rate, provides a quick, powerful win.

This victory releases dopamine, builds confidence, and creates the momentum needed to stick with the plan for the long haul.

This phenomenon, where people show a preference for closing out small accounts, has even been termed “debt account aversion” by researchers.³⁶

One method is not inherently “better” than the other.

They are simply designed for different psychological operating systems.

The choice between them is a diagnostic tool.

Are you a person motivated by pure efficiency and optimization? The Avalanche is your tool.

Are you a person who thrives on momentum, feedback, and the feeling of progress? The Snowball is for you.

A Financial Permaculture approach doesn’t prescribe one; it helps you discover which tool fits you, making your entire plan more diverse and resilient.

Feature	Debt Snowball (The Momentum Engine)	Debt Avalanche (The Optimization Engine)
Core Principle	Pay off debts from smallest balance to largest.	Pay off debts from highest interest rate to lowest.
Best For…	Individuals who need to see progress to stay motivated; those feeling overwhelmed by the number of debts.	Individuals who are disciplined and motivated by numbers and long-term efficiency.
Primary Motivation	Behavioral and psychological momentum.	Mathematical and financial optimization.
Psychological Reward	Quick, frequent wins as small debts are eliminated, building confidence and habit.	The satisfaction of knowing you are paying the least amount of interest possible.
Key Drawback	You will pay more in total interest compared to the avalanche method.	Progress can feel slow at first if your highest-interest debt also has a large balance.
The Math	Sub-optimal. Costs more over time.	Optimal. Saves the most money.

Sources: ³²

From Barren to Bountiful

After my permaculture epiphany, the first person I called was Anna.

I explained my new thinking, admitting that the system I had given her was too rigid for her dynamic life.

We threw out the old blueprint and started over, not as architects, but as gardeners.

First, we simply observed.

For one month, she tracked her income and spending without any goal other than to see the patterns.

We learned that her creative energy, and thus her income, peaked in the weeks after a big project was paid for, and her spending on things like art supplies and self-care followed suit.

Next, we focused on catching and storing energy.

Her number one goal became building a one-month income buffer.

It took three months of intense focus, channeling every extra dollar from a couple of big client payments into her holding account.

But the day she did it was the day everything changed.

On the first of the following month, she paid herself a fixed, predictable “salary” for the first time in her freelance career.

The anxiety that had been her constant companion vanished.

We also set up sinking funds for her quarterly tax payments, her annual software subscriptions, and a future new laptop—the very “surprise” expenses that had previously sent her to her credit cards.

With a stable “income” to work with, we could now apply self-regulation using a living zero-based budget.

Her monthly plan was now based on her predictable salary, not her volatile cash flow.

It was realistic and calm.

Finally, we valued her diversity.

We talked about the debt snowball versus the avalanche.

Anna knew instantly she was a “Snowball” person.

The idea of chipping away at a huge loan for a year with little visible progress was deflating.

But the thought of wiping out her smallest store credit card in a month? That was exciting.

She listed her debts and attacked the smallest one.

Two months later, it was gone.

That victory propelled her to the next, and the next.

In just under a year, using the exact same income that had previously pushed her deeper into debt, she paid off all her credit cards.³⁹

She wasn’t just debt-free; she was in control, confident, and free from the shame that the “perfect” budget had imposed on her.

Conclusion: Stop Following Rules, Start Cultivating Your Life

The world of personal finance is filled with people selling blueprints.

They offer you seven simple steps, three easy categories, or ten magic percentages that promise to solve all your problems.

But a life cannot be lived from a blueprint.

A life, like a garden, is a complex, ever-changing, living ecosystem.

True financial well-being isn’t about finding the perfect set of rules and forcing your life to comply.

It’s about becoming a skilled and patient gardener of your own circumstances.

It’s about taking the time to observe your unique landscape—your income, your habits, your personality, your goals.

It’s about designing a system that works with your natural contours, one that builds in resilience to weather the inevitable droughts and storms.

It’s about nurturing that system with conscious, intentional choices, learning from feedback, and celebrating the diversity that makes you who you are.

The goal is not to have a perfect budget.

The goal is to build a life with less stress, more freedom, and greater abundance.

Stop searching for a better blueprint.

The map you need is already there, in the patterns of your own life.

It’s time to pick up your trowel and start observing your garden.

Works cited

1. 7 Common Money Issues People Face | SoFi, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.sofi.com/learn/content/common-money-issues/
2. I wish there were more videos of lower income people like myself : r/DaveRamsey – Reddit, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/DaveRamsey/comments/1lp7vjb/i_wish_there_were_more_videos_of_lower_income/
3. Struggling to effectively budget : r/DaveRamsey – Reddit, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/DaveRamsey/comments/1bhtuec/struggling_to_effectively_budget/
4. I Make $200,000 and Have Nothing To Show For It – YouTube, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mzkD5b9QqvM&pp=0gcJCfwAo7VqN5tD
5. How to Budget With Irregular Income: 6 Steps for Success – Ramsey Solutions, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.ramseysolutions.com/budgeting/how-to-budget-an-irregular-income
6. Zero-Based Budgeting: What It Is and How to Make It Work for You – Ramsey Solutions, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.ramseysolutions.com/budgeting/how-to-make-a-zero-based-budget
7. The Dave Ramsey Budget: Is it Realistic? – Debt.org, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.debt.org/advice/dave-ramsey-budget/
8. Recommended monthly budget percentages, accessed August 7, 2025, https://sacscoc.shsu.edu/Support%20Docs/12.6/7%20-%20Recommended%20Monthly%20Budget%20Percentages%20Information%20Sheet.pdf
9. Recommended Percentages, accessed August 7, 2025, https://cdn.ramseysolutions.net/pdf/fpu/fpuonline/recommended_budget_percentages.pdf?_ga=2.91044314.1534858441.1631545741-242371793.1611160690&_gac=1.261471871.1631220373.Cj0KCQjw4eaJBhDMARIsANhrQACdZaWQX7xY4hpDVTMk_UZNqgVlKSePTgveEdB9hMFZpMYSkJI8YK0aAkzSEALw_wcB
10. The 50/30/20 Budget Rule Explained – Ramsey Solutions, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.ramseysolutions.com/budgeting/50-20-30-budget-rule
11. How Much Cash Should I Keep in the Bank? – Investopedia, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.investopedia.com/articles/personal-finance/040915/how-much-cash-should-i-keep-bank.asp
12. Consumer Expenditures–2023 – 2023 A01 Results – Bureau of Labor Statistics, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.bls.gov/news.release/cesan.nr0.htm
13. Consumer expenditures in 2022 : BLS Reports – Bureau of Labor Statistics, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.bls.gov/opub/reports/consumer-expenditures/2022/
14. CMV: Budget culture does more harm than good : r/changemyview – Reddit, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/changemyview/comments/1jykfh4/cmv_budget_culture_does_more_harm_than_good/
15. 5 Reasons Why Your Budget Isn’t Working – Indiana, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.in.gov/sos/indianamoneywise/blog/posts/5-reasons-why-your-budget-isnt-working/
16. 3 Common Budgeting Challenges to Overcome – Investopedia, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.investopedia.com/personal-finance/common-budgeting-challenges-overcome/
17. Implementing the Zero-Based Budgeting Approach | Monefy, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.monefy.com/article/implementing-zero-based-budgeting-approach
18. Zero-Based Budgeting Explained: Maximize Every Dollar, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.incharge.org/financial-literacy/budgeting-saving/zero-based-budgeting/
19. Irregular Income | YNAB, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.ynab.com/guide/irregular-income
20. Zero-Based Budgeting: What It Is And How It Works – NerdWallet, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/finance/zero-based-budgeting-explained
21. I used to follow a zero-based budget because that’s what everyone recommends, but I switched to an automatic budget and boosted my savings rate significantly : r/personalfinance – Reddit, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/personalfinance/comments/7p9hb1/i_used_to_follow_a_zerobased_budget_because_thats/
22. Budget Percentages – Ramsey Solutions, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.ramseysolutions.com/budgeting/budget-percentages
23. Ramsey Solutions, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.ramseysolutions.com/
24. Dave Ramsey’s 7 Baby Steps, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.ramseysolutions.com/dave-ramsey-7-baby-steps
25. Dave Ramsey’s 7 Baby Steps for Financial Success | Bills.com, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.bills.com/personal-finance/dave-ramsey-baby-steps
26. How to Win With Money in 7 Baby Steps – Ramsey Solutions, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.ramseysolutions.com/budgeting/how-to-win-with-money-in-7-easy-baby-steps
27. Dave Ramsey’s 7 Budgeting Baby Steps – Check City, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.checkcity.com/personal-finance/dave-ramseys-7-baby-steps
28. The Importance of Giving Back – Ramsey Solutions, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.ramseysolutions.com/budgeting/importance-of-giving-back
29. Tithes and Offerings: Your Questions Answered – Ramsey Solutions, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.ramseysolutions.com/budgeting/daves-advice-on-tithing-and-giving
30. Why do you think Dave Ramsey encourages giving as part of building wealth – Reddit, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/DaveRamsey/comments/1g8izpq/why_do_you_think_dave_ramsey_encourages_giving_as/
31. The Behavioral Science Behind Paying Your Debts – The Decision Lab, accessed August 7, 2025, https://thedecisionlab.com/insights/consumer-insights/behavioral-science-of-paying-debts
32. Debt snowball method vs. debt avalanche method: Which is right for you? | Fidelity, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.fidelity.com/learning-center/personal-finance/avalanche-snowball-debt
33. Two Paths to Freedom: The Debt Snowball vs. The Debt Avalanche – Wings for Widows, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.wingsforwidows.org/popular-articles/two-paths-to-freedom-the-debt-snowball-vs-the-debt-avalanche
34. A snowball’s chance: Debt snowball vs. debt avalanche, accessed August 7, 2025, https://commons.lib.jmu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1672&context=honors201019
35. Analyzing Loan Repayment Behavior With Behavioral Economics – BharatLoan, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.bharatloan.com/blog/analyzing-loan-repayment-behavior-using-behavioral-economics
36. What Psychology Tells Us About Reducing Our Debts – Hustle Escape, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.hustleescape.com/psychology-of-reducing-debts/
37. Snowball vs. Avalanche: Choosing Your Debt Repayment Path – MyEarnup, accessed August 7, 2025, https://myearnup.com/snowball-vs-avalanche/
38. Snowball vs. Avalanche Method for Paying Down Debt | Navy Federal Credit Union, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.navyfederal.org/makingcents/credit-debt/snowball-vs-avalanche-for-paying-down-debt.html
39. Any success stories with a below average income? : r/DaveRamsey – Reddit, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/DaveRamsey/comments/853bvk/any_success_stories_with_a_below_average_income/
40. From $101,000 in Debt to Baby Step 4: Phillip’s Story – Ramsey, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.ramseysolutions.com/retirement/phillip-from-debt-to-baby-step-4
41. 4 Real Budgeters Share How Their Lives Have Changed – Ramsey Solutions, accessed August 7, 2025, https://www.ramseysolutions.com/budgeting/budgeter-success-stories-with-everydollar